FREE SHIPPING ON ALL ORDERS!

PB Cookies: You’ve Got Options!

At Tasty Expressions, a cookie is never just a cookie; we want our fans to explore all of the creative ways our cookies can be used beyond the traditional bite! If you haven’t considered switching it up with your next order of Chef Boyd's Famous Chunky Peanut Butter Cookies, let us convince you with these fun ideas!

Ice cream sandwiches: Sandwich your favorite ice cream between two cookies and you’ve got quite a substantial treat! Our favorite is a good classic vanilla to compliment the ultra peanut-buttery flavor of these crumbly cookies. Pro tip: Eat the sandwich over a plate and dip the ice cream sides back into the fallen crumbles. You won’t want to waste a single crumb!

Ice cream/shake flavors: Our Chunky Peanut Butter Cookies make a great addition to an ice cream or shake base. Vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry work great, but if you can dream it, you can do it! We look forward to seeing what sort of creative pairings you imagine! Pro tip: Be careful not to over-blend after adding your cookies to preserve some texture!

Pies: Have you ever had a cookie pie crust? Making one couldn’t be easier. Crush your cookies and mix them with some butter before pressing them to the bottom and sides of your pie pan or tin! Ensure that you’ve pressed the cookie mixture in firmly so as to prevent any seepage. The natural texture of these cookies lend very well to this technique! The filling options are endless, as long as they compliment peanut butter. Left at a coarse texture, our Peanut Butter Cookies also make a great pie crumble!

Cocktail rims: Line the rim of your next dessert cocktail with crushed peanut butter cookies! We like to use a syrup to ensure the cookies don’t fall off. Depending on your drink of choice, we recommend sweetened condensed milk, chocolate syrup, or our favorite, Salted Caramel Sauce. Pro tip: Keep a few whole cookies handy on the side for when those cocktails kick in!

Trifles/Icebox cakes: Used in a similar fashion, our cookies make a great addition to a variety of trifle and icebox cake recipes. They can be incorporated and moistened by the interior or used as a crumble at the top or throughout. Pro tip: Mid-sized pieces can be heated with a bit of melted butter to make rich, yummy cookie croutons for your next layered dessert or sundae!

“Sand”: Have you been planning to create a beach scene on or around your next dessert? Fake sand made from the fine cookie dust of our peanut butter cookies looks just like the real thing, and tastes even better than it looks! Get creative with your cookie dust and ride the wave of decadent peanut butter as it crashes around your mouth. We’ve been known to have a straight spoonful (or two).

Whether you like to keep it classic or are looking to switch it up, our peanut butter cookies are guaranteed to satisfy! Experience the addictive flavor and texture yourself, or gift them to a friend (beware of peanut allergies!). Any way you eat them, they’re great!

Before you add Chef Boyd’s Famous Chunky Peanut Butter Cookies to your cart, add yourself to our email list to earn a personal code for 20% off! Learn about upcoming promotions and new product launches first. We promise less spam, and more cake!